Last EB meeting: Chinese wind and hydro facing challenges

17 Feb 2010 13:41

POINT CARBON ANALYSIS - At its 52nd meeting, from 8 to 12 February in Bonn, the EB rejected a total of 12 projects: six Chinese wind projects, four energy efficiency projects (three from China, one from India), one fugitive emissions project from coal mines, and one Indian wind project. The EB is continuing to scrutinise Chinese wind projects. It is now also throwing a large share of Chinese hydro projects into the review loop. With regards to DOEs, the EB continues to implement its new accreditation procedures and stricter requirements on how they perform their work.

Do you want to read more?

Access to this page requires subscription

You have entered a part of our site that requires a username and password.
If you are already a subscriber please sign in using the log in fields on the left side of this page.

Not a subscriber to Point Carbon’s services?
For a free trial or more information about this product please contact sales@pointcarbon.com or call one of the following numbers to reach our Sales Team:

Point Carbon Head Office (Oslo)
Phone: +47 22 40 53 40

Point Carbon (Washington):
Phone: +1 202 289 3930

Latest analyst updates

26 Oct 10 Can REDD, finance and MRV make it in Cancun? POINT CARBON ANALYSIS – The UN climate negotiations are stuck with seemingly irreconcilable stances on key issues, mainly along the developing-industrialized country divide. The upcoming negotiating session on Cancun may offer some limited progress toward breaking stalemates over i) financing and MRV, and ii) market mechanisms for avoided deforestation. The overriding question of what form an international climate agreement should take, will be punted to next year’s COP in Johannesburg. Buy/Free trial
15 Oct 10 Decision on 30% target could be postponed to 2012 The EU environment ministers decided to postpone the discussion on the 30% reduction target at the Environment Council meeting in Luxembourg on 14 October. The discussion might resurface when the EU leaders meet for the European Council in March 2011, but it seems more likely that a final decision will be taken in 2012. Buy/Free trial
13 Oct 10 Tianjin outcome: limited prospects for Cancun POINT CARBON ANALYSIS – Last week’s climate negotiations in Tianjin, China, saw little progress toward potential concrete outcomes at the high-level round of talks taking place in Mexico in two months The entrenched positions – and even the negotiating texts to be discussed in Cancun – have not changed. However, rules on accounting for emissions from land use change may emerge in December, and this may facilitate progress on REDD. Parties also gained momentum on finance. Buy/Free trial
01 Oct 10 Talkin’ in Tianjin: can they shorten the negotiating texts? POINT CARBON ANALYSIS – Expectations are low for the upcoming round of climate negotiations in Tianjin, China. We see the section of negotiating text on finance as most likely to progress in the six days available, while options on mitigation will likely remain foggy and bogged down in brackets. The Tianjin talks will be successful to the extent that they result in a shorter, less ambiguous negotiating text with clear options for the higher-level diplomats to decide on in Cancun. Buy/Free trial
01 Oct 10 "Short seven" still need to act on Kyoto deficits POINT CARBON ANALYSIS –The updated Kyoto balance shows seven countries being short, the same as in June, with Spain, Italy and Japan displaying the greatest projected Kyoto unit deficits. The deficits of the seven countries total 332 Mt over the 2008-12 period. This is up from 283 Mt in June. The main reason for the increase is that Italy has reduced its governmental purchasing plan for CERs, ERUs and AAUs. Buy/Free trial
01 Oct 10 Kyoto period credit balance shows CER/ERU surplus POINT CARBON ANALYSIS – Our updated CER/ERU balance shows an estimated surplus of 313 million CERs and ERUs over the 2008-12 period. This is the first surplus since Point Carbon began tracking the balance between the supply and demand of CERs and ERUs. The change in our forecast is mainly due to the fact that we have given AAU purchases a more prominent role in our calculations. Notably, we expect a large share of residual credit demand – the expected emissions that will not be covered by current credit purchasing plans – to be filled using AAUs. Buy/Free trial
22 Sep 10 Towards harmony for large hydro CERs in the EU ETS? POINT CARBON ANALYSIS: All Member States have since July 2009 used the EU Commission’s harmonised guidelines when approving large hydro CDM projects. These guidelines have made it clearer what is required for a large hydro project to comply with the WCD criteria and the buyers do no longer have to consider which country to seek investor country approval from. The introduction of the guidelines has, however, not led to more large hydro projects entering the EU ETS, primary CER prices are still lower than for other project types and the exchanges have yet to allow for trading of sCERs from large hydro projects. Buy/Free trial
15 Sep 10 One step closer to a Japanese ETS POINT CARBON ANALYSIS – Japanese Prime Minister Naoto Kan won yesterday’s scheduled leadership vote in the Democratic Party of Japan (DPJ). Kan’s clear victory removes an important potential hurdle on the way toward passing the Basic Law on Global Warming in the Diet. Passing the Basic Law would pave the way for the introduction of a Japanese ETS starting 1 April 2013, although legislative congestion could lead to a postponement until 2014. Buy/Free trial
14 Sep 10 UNFCCC Secretariat u-turn on post-2012 CDM POINT CARBON ANALYSIS – Recently published clarifications on post-2012 on the CDM EB webpages brush aside any doubt about the role of CDM. This is a surprising u-turn, as the Secretariat issued a note in June on the implications of a gap between commitment periods that signalled a much more uncertain future for CDM. The message is crystal clear: All aspects of CDM will continue post-2012, regardless of whether Annex I countries inscribe post-2012 reduction targets in the Kyoto Protocol or not. Buy/Free trial
02 Sep 10 The likely shape of a Japanese ETS POINT CARBON ANALYSIS – The Japanese Ministry of the Environment released recommendations for the country’s planned emission trading scheme (ETS) on 31 August. Among three main design options, the most likely appears to be a hybrid system with an absolute cap for industrial and commercial sectors and intensity-based targets for the power sector. No recommendation is made on how to share the reduction burden within the ETS or between ETS and non-ETS sectors. Although the proposed start date is 1 April 2013, as expected, the main barrier for an ETS still seems to be the ability of the governing Democratic Party of Japan to pass the legislative framework for emission trading during the extraordinary autumn session of the Diet. Buy/Free trial

26 Oct 10

Can REDD, finance and MRV make it in Cancun?

POINT CARBON ANALYSIS – The UN climate negotiations are stuck with seemingly irreconcilable stances on key issues, mainly along the developing-industrialized country divide. The upcoming negotiating session on Cancun may offer some limited progress toward breaking stalemates over i) financing and MRV, and ii) market mechanisms for avoided deforestation. The overriding question of what form an international climate agreement should take, will be punted to next year’s COP in Johannesburg.

Buy/Free trial You do not have access to this article

15 Oct 10

Decision on 30% target could be postponed to 2012

The EU environment ministers decided to postpone the discussion on the 30% reduction target at the Environment Council meeting in Luxembourg on 14 October. The discussion might resurface when the EU leaders meet for the European Council in March 2011, but it seems more likely that a final decision will be taken in 2012.

Buy/Free trial You do not have access to this article

13 Oct 10

Tianjin outcome: limited prospects for Cancun

POINT CARBON ANALYSIS – Last week’s climate negotiations in Tianjin, China, saw little progress toward potential concrete outcomes at the high-level round of talks taking place in Mexico in two months The entrenched positions – and even the negotiating texts to be discussed in Cancun – have not changed. However, rules on accounting for emissions from land use change may emerge in December, and this may facilitate progress on REDD. Parties also gained momentum on finance.

Buy/Free trial You do not have access to this article

01 Oct 10

Talkin’ in Tianjin: can they shorten the negotiating texts?

POINT CARBON ANALYSIS – Expectations are low for the upcoming round of climate negotiations in Tianjin, China. We see the section of negotiating text on finance as most likely to progress in the six days available, while options on mitigation will likely remain foggy and bogged down in brackets. The Tianjin talks will be successful to the extent that they result in a shorter, less ambiguous negotiating text with clear options for the higher-level diplomats to decide on in Cancun.

Buy/Free trial You do not have access to this article

01 Oct 10

"Short seven" still need to act on Kyoto deficits

POINT CARBON ANALYSIS –The updated Kyoto balance shows seven countries being short, the same as in June, with Spain, Italy and Japan displaying the greatest projected Kyoto unit deficits. The deficits of the seven countries total 332 Mt over the 2008-12 period. This is up from 283 Mt in June. The main reason for the increase is that Italy has reduced its governmental purchasing plan for CERs, ERUs and AAUs.

Buy/Free trial You do not have access to this article

01 Oct 10

Kyoto period credit balance shows CER/ERU surplus

POINT CARBON ANALYSIS – Our updated CER/ERU balance shows an estimated surplus of 313 million CERs and ERUs over the 2008-12 period. This is the first surplus since Point Carbon began tracking the balance between the supply and demand of CERs and ERUs. The change in our forecast is mainly due to the fact that we have given AAU purchases a more prominent role in our calculations. Notably, we expect a large share of residual credit demand – the expected emissions that will not be covered by current credit purchasing plans – to be filled using AAUs.

Buy/Free trial You do not have access to this article

22 Sep 10

Towards harmony for large hydro CERs in the EU ETS?

POINT CARBON ANALYSIS: All Member States have since July 2009 used the EU Commission’s harmonised guidelines when approving large hydro CDM projects. These guidelines have made it clearer what is required for a large hydro project to comply with the WCD criteria and the buyers do no longer have to consider which country to seek investor country approval from. The introduction of the guidelines has, however, not led to more large hydro projects entering the EU ETS, primary CER prices are still lower than for other project types and the exchanges have yet to allow for trading of sCERs from large hydro projects.

Buy/Free trial You do not have access to this article

15 Sep 10

One step closer to a Japanese ETS

POINT CARBON ANALYSIS – Japanese Prime Minister Naoto Kan won yesterday’s scheduled leadership vote in the Democratic Party of Japan (DPJ). Kan’s clear victory removes an important potential hurdle on the way toward passing the Basic Law on Global Warming in the Diet. Passing the Basic Law would pave the way for the introduction of a Japanese ETS starting 1 April 2013, although legislative congestion could lead to a postponement until 2014.

Buy/Free trial You do not have access to this article

14 Sep 10

UNFCCC Secretariat u-turn on post-2012 CDM

POINT CARBON ANALYSIS – Recently published clarifications on post-2012 on the CDM EB webpages brush aside any doubt about the role of CDM. This is a surprising u-turn, as the Secretariat issued a note in June on the implications of a gap between commitment periods that signalled a much more uncertain future for CDM. The message is crystal clear: All aspects of CDM will continue post-2012, regardless of whether Annex I countries inscribe post-2012 reduction targets in the Kyoto Protocol or not.

Buy/Free trial You do not have access to this article

02 Sep 10

The likely shape of a Japanese ETS

POINT CARBON ANALYSIS – The Japanese Ministry of the Environment released recommendations for the country’s planned emission trading scheme (ETS) on 31 August. Among three main design options, the most likely appears to be a hybrid system with an absolute cap for industrial and commercial sectors and intensity-based targets for the power sector. No recommendation is made on how to share the reduction burden within the ETS or between ETS and non-ETS sectors. Although the proposed start date is 1 April 2013, as expected, the main barrier for an ETS still seems to be the ability of the governing Democratic Party of Japan to pass the legislative framework for emission trading during the extraordinary autumn session of the Diet.

Buy/Free trial You do not have access to this article